By Talk to a Lawyer · Published 20 September 2026 · 3 minute read
Explore disputes & resolution guides →
A settlement offer is more than a number. It may ask you to release claims, make promises, pay costs or complete steps by particular dates. Before deciding, identify what is being offered and what you would give up or undertake in return. Keep the complete proposal and ask for advice about the terms and the process for accepting it.
Identify exactly what the offer covers
List the parties and issues named in the proposal. Ask whether the offer resolves all parts of the dispute or only a defined part. A broad release may need careful explanation, particularly if another claim, insurer, employer or related person is involved.
Keep the proposed agreement with the letter or email that delivered it. The wording about timing, acceptance and costs may appear outside the main document. Do not assume that accepting the headline amount leaves every other term open for later negotiation.
Work through the practical obligations
Make a table of who must do what and by when. Include payment, document delivery, repairs, withdrawal of proceedings or other promised actions. Ask how completion is confirmed and what happens if a step is late or cannot be performed.
If the offer includes confidentiality, non-disparagement or continuing restrictions, ask what conduct they cover and what exceptions or advice you need. Terms that sound routine can still affect future choices. Request plain-language explanations of obligations you do not understand.
Understand costs and the net result
Ask your adviser to explain the amount you would actually receive or pay after relevant legal costs, expenses and other items requiring consideration. Identify tax, benefits, insurance or financial questions that need another professional's input rather than assuming the settlement figure answers them.
Compare acceptance with realistic alternatives, including the cost, uncertainty and time of continuing. Ask what assumptions support that comparison. A decision should be informed by your actual circumstances, not a general promise about winning or a result advertised for someone else.
Clarify acceptance and the next step
Ask how acceptance must occur, whether there is an expiry date and whether any formal approval or further document is needed. Do not assume an informal reply has no effect, or that signing is the only possible way an agreement can arise. Get advice before communicating a decision you do not understand.
If you accept, keep the completed agreement and a task list for implementation. If you reject or propose changes, confirm who sends the response and what happens next. Continue to track any separate procedural dates while the proposal is being considered.
Keep this checklist beside you
0 of 4 gathered · ticks reset when you leave this page.
A preparation aid, not confirmation that a legal requirement is complete.
Common questions
Is an offer safe to accept if the amount looks fair?
Ask about all the terms and their effect before deciding. Releases, costs, restrictions and implementation can change the practical result even when the headline amount is acceptable.
Can I keep negotiating after saying yes?
Do not assume that every acceptance leaves the terms open. Ask for advice about how a response may operate before sending it, particularly if you intend to accept only part of the proposal.
Sources and scope
General appointment preparation, not advice about your individual circumstances. Examples are illustrative, not client case studies. Sources provide further reading; confirm current requirements with the relevant service or adviser.
- Federal Court: mediation
Federal Court mediation information; check the requirements of the particular court, scheme or private process.
- Legal Aid NSW: dealing with your lawyer
NSW legal-profession complaints and service issues; other professions have different regulators and rules.
Keep exploring
The preparation desk · Local legal-help guides
Preparing for mediation: decisions, documents and realistic options
Build a mediation preparation pack with issues, options, decision authority, practical costs and questions about recording any agreement.
How to compare two legal quotes without comparing different jobs
Read legal quotes side by side: scope, assumptions, exclusions, external expenses and the point where a new estimate is needed.